I consider myself a Taylor Swift fan, even though I’m not necessarily a fan of her music. Still, if one of her songs come on the radio, I won’t turn the station. In a world full of Lady Gagas and Katy Perrys that cause me to risk driving off the road in an effort to change the radio station as quickly as possible, Taylor Swift’s music is a calming, pleasant alternative.
No, it’s the idea of Taylor Swift of which I’m a fan. She seems like a nice person. She seems like a good role model. She dresses modestly, she’s never been caught doing something inappropriate, and her overly-romantic song lyrics are generally wholesome.
In short, she’s the anti-Miley Cyrus. The anti-Britney Spears. The anti-Christina Aguilera. The anti-practically every other female musician.
But I now have a beef with her.
While on YouTube recently, I noticed a huge advertisement for her new music video. I clicked on it and watched it. Ninety-nine percent of those who watch it will likely think it’s a sweet, harmless, romantic video.
I am not within that 99%.
In the video, Taylor Swift meets a guy. They fall in love. They move in together. He proposes. They get married, have children and live happily ever after.
These events happen in the order I listed them.
Again, 99% will not notice anything wrong. And that, to me, is precisely the problem.
Jacob and Taylor sittin’ in a tree
K-I-S-S-I-N-G
First comes love
Then comes marriage
Then comes a baby in a baby carriage
Remember that playground song from your childhood? I sure do. And I can’t help but notice there is no mention of living together before you’re married!
Why, given the fact much of her fan base are impressionable children and teenagers, did Taylor Swift choose to perpetuate the notion living together before marriage is how things are done? Clearly, she sees nothing wrong with it. And that, of course, is her choice. She’s free to live her life. But to write a song and make a video that romanticizes it? Really?
I guess I just expected more of Taylor Swift based on what I thought I knew of her. But the moral, I suppose, is none of us really know what goes on in the minds and lives of celebrities. The same man who gave us The Passion, Mel Gibson, is a lonely man with serious issues. The star of Hogan’s Heroes was a sex addict. And Sean Penn…well, I can’t really think of anything positive to say about Sean Penn. Him being a tool really isn’t a shocker.
Yes, I know, I am old-fashioned. Of course, old-fashioned is just another way of saying I have a moral compass of by which I abide. I’m old-fashioned and proud of it. And my Taylor Swift fandom has taken a serious hit.
I'm a cypher, wrapped in an enigma, smothered in secret sauce. Also, my name is Kev and I own this here website.
















;-) 8.31.10 at 1:39 pm:
Be proud of your old-fashioned-ness! I am…for practical, statistical reasons, but mostly spiritual reasons.
Still…there are statistical reasons!
http://www.leaderu.com/critical/cohabitation-socio.html
;-) 8.31.10 at 3:38 pm:
Aw, shucks! I hadn’t seen that video or heard the song. I’ve always been a fan of Taylor Swift, and now that’s taken a hit. Right there with you with the old-fashioned values and the moral compass.
(P.S. My Kevin would like me to mention that he has never liked Taylor Swift, so this song/video doesn’t change anything for him.)
;-) 8.31.10 at 10:28 pm:
Okay, if you think less of her now, then I don’t even want to tell you she was messing around the King Douchebag, John Mayer, a few months ago. Yeah, she’s been tainted.
;-) 9.1.10 at 7:05 pm:
I didn’t know that was in her video, but then I don’t know much about her videos. Like you, I thought she was sweet and wholesome and overall a good (if rather unrealistic) role model. Shame on her for caving to the pressure that says, better depict girls as captains of their own little vessels, answerable to no one, and it’s okay to do it before marriage as long as you’re “in love.”
Wonder if Swifty would have the courage to show girls the sad, tawdry, and often violent outcome of sleeping with men without benefit of marriage? Nobody ever wants to talk about the consequences of these illicit choices.
;-) 9.1.10 at 7:07 pm:
Oh and … great post, Kev. You deserve many more readers and commenters! You’re one of the best bloggers out there. God bless you, friend.
;-) 9.7.10 at 2:28 pm:
@Angi: Will do. I’ll be loud and proud!
@Ellen: Tell Kevin he wins this round. But don’t let it go to his head.
@brookeamanda: John Mayer? Yeah, I so did not need to know that. Unbelievable.
@Jenny: You hit the nail on the head. Why have good “celebrity” role models gone the way of the dodo? It’s sad.
Ah, thanks! You’re much too kind.